Cheapest and Top Rated Car Insurance Companies in Brooklyn (2022)

Top Rated Car Insurance: Car insurance is one of the most important purchases that a person makes. Every year, thousands of people purchase a new car. Whether it is a new car or a used car, car insurance is a must.

Most car owners don’t think about spending money to buy the best rated car insurance. Even if they do, they don’t spend the extra money to get the best deal.

Top Rated Car Insurance Companies

Car insurance is more than just protection for your car. It is protection for you and your family in case of an accident. It is also protection for anyone else who may be involved in the accident. With a good insurance policy, you are covered for both the car damage and the medical expenses.

This is a guide to the top rated cheap car insurance companies in brooklyn. If you have a car, you need to ensure that you are covered in case of an accident.

This is because the amount of damage that you sustain will depend on the severity of the accident and the insurance company will help you pay for that damage.

Cheapest and Top Rated Car Insurance Companies in Brooklyn
Cheapest and Top Rated Car Insurance Companies in Brooklyn

USAA Car Insurance

USAA is an independent insurance company that covers members of the United States military and their families. With USAA, car insurance policies are typically based on a customer’s driving record and depend on how likely they are to be involved in an accident or face other types of emergency situations while they are behind the wheel.

USAA is considered best-in-class when compared to the competition, though it isn’t included in a J.D. Power study because it only sells its products online and to existing customers, like active duty service members who already have an existing account with the company.


Geico is one of the most robust auto insurance discount programs available in the marketplace today. A number of discounts are available: for example, if you’re a federal employee, the military, if you’ve purchased safety features on your car or have been accident-free for five years.

If you’re looking for highly personalized coverage that includes lots of options such as purchasing additional coverage types like towing and roadside assistance, Geico might not be an ideal choice since it tends to stick with its traditional business model as an extremely affordable auto insurance provider that emphasizes saving people money instead of offering many extras like other providers might.

Cheapest Car Insurance Companies

State Farm

State Farm offers auto, homeowners, renters, life insurance and banking services as well as other more general forms of insurance. However, if you already have another policy with a different company that does not overlap with State Farm , it may not be the most cost-efficient to get additional policies with the same company.

The company has an extensive network of agents – including some that may be local – so keep this in mind if you want to work with somebody closer. Because State Farm operates in all 50 states in America, you can search for agents located nearby.

Though prices vary by agent and location, the average premium is similar to others compared to State Farm.


Progressive has the cheapest full coverage car insurance quote for drivers who live in brooklyn out of the carriers on this list.

In addition to having low rates, you may be able to save even more by taking advantage of discounts like getting your rate by quoting over the phone or online; or being able to sign up for a policy and get started right away via an emailed link.

Or, if you want to go paperless with your insurance policy, another great way to get discounts is by dealing with Progressive directly so you aren’t caught spending money sending those important documents through the mail or paying someone outside of Progressive to file those necessary forms!


If you’re shopping for the cheapest car insurance, Allstate is a good option. The company boasts very low average premiums and offers a range of discounts to help keep them low.

Even though Allstate offers some great discounts, the positive aspects may not outweigh the higher than average premiums in some states, especially when comparing it to companies offering nearly identical policies with lower rates.

By shopping around and comparing top providers as you research your policy needs, you can find more affordable coverage that serves your needs.

If you want something more affordable, take advantage of Allstate’s discounts, which include savings for safe drivers, new vehicles and smart students. Also note that most of the additional coverage add-ons for your automobile may still be more affordable than buying separate plans through third-party insurance companies!

Liberty Mutual

A lot of people can claim to have good car insurance. But, not many can say that they are the leaders in providing customers with do-it-yourself quotes for their auto insurance options.

With Liberty Mutual’s use of a quote calculator and searchable website that is easy to understand and navigate, it allows customers to offer the option to get an auto insurance quote in minutes.

Allowing the customer to be able to affordably get the type of coverage they want from a company who has proven themselves as having good rates and customer service over time.

Liberty Mutual offers very competitive prices as compared to other auto insurers, so if you are shopping around then you may want to keep this name at the top of your list when it comes time for renewal!


Nationwide is a good insurance company with generally positive reviews from its customers. However, it didn’t do particularly well in any one area that really stood out among the competition, though where it fell short in some key areas like the claims process or how claims were resolved, Nationwide stands out in areas like customer service and price.

Nationwide provides good service overall and does well across the board when it comes to nearly all of the aspects that were tested but particularly excelled in our price estimator tool.

However, there were certain downsides to using their auto insurance services that kept it from being a higher performer in our rankings such as survey respondents indicating they had less positive experiences throughout the claims process or once their claim was closed.

Final Thoughts

We hope you enjoyed our article about the cheapest and top rated car insurance companies in brooklyn. With this knowledge, we know that you can get the best deal on your car insurance policy and make sure you are covered for all of life’s little accidents.


Click to rate this post!
[Total: 0 Average: 0]

Leave a Comment